How to Choose the Right Pet Insurance for You and Your Dog

How to Choose Pet Insurance | Vanillapup

Want to buy an insurance policy for your pet? How do you compare offerings by different companies and what should you take note of? Here’s a helpful guide.

We get a lot of emails and messages from people who are keen on getting pet insurance for their dogs. The common questions are “What’s the difference between the different pet insurance offerings in the market?”, “Which pet insurance is the best?”, “Does pet insurance cover this and that?”, and “Should I buy insurance for my dog?”

The truth is, we can’t tell you which insurance plan is best for you and your dog. That’s because everyone’s situation and budget are different. So, instead, we hope that this guide will help you make a better decision.

Here goes!

Why buy pet insurance?

Our pets can get sick or injured, and treatments can sometimes cost a lot of money. Even if your dog is healthy, she may get into trouble now and then, such as swallowing a foreign object.

The main purpose of a pet insurance plan is to help you pay for the big medical bills.

With help to shoulder eligible medical expenses:

  • Your pet gets timely treatment because you can afford it
  • You may be able to seek better quality healthcare for your pet
  • You can focus on being there for your pet and not worry too much about the bills

The types of pet insurance coverage

In Singapore, you can find the following types of coverage:

  1. Accidental death & injury
  2. Non-surgery-related treatment
  3. Surgery-related treatment
  4. Room and board fees
  5. Post-surgery treatment
  6. Specific disease, such as cancer treatment
  7. Third-party liability
  8. Theft
  9. Final expenses

Overseas, some insurance may also cover:

  1. Overseas travel medical expenses
  2. Dental treatment due to accident and/or illness
  3. Missing pet advertising fees

Know your needs

Your priority is to protect your savings from unexpected big bills. So, you will have to think about where those bills may likely come from. I know, if it’s going to be unexpected, how can you anticipate it?

While we can’t be 100% sure what bills, if at all, you may end up having to incur for your pet, a few questions may help you make a better decision. For example, is your dog(‘s):

  • breed prone to expensive health problems?
  • not well-bred or has an unknown medical history?
  • at an age when she’s prone to illnesses that are expensive to treat?
  • prone to accidents that may incur huge medical bills?
  • likely to cause harm to a third party?

Those questions will help you decide whether you need pet insurance and if you do, what sort of insurance coverage you can’t compromise on. You may even want to buy more than one insurance plan to get wider coverage.

We didn’t buy insurance for Latte until she was almost four years old. To be honest, I took a gamble that she wouldn’t need to claim insurance yet. She has luxating patella as a pre-existing condition and skin issues. Both of which would not be claimable under any available insurance plans. Luckily, besides the long-term management of her skin problems, she has a clean bill of health so far.

You should also understand that you are not buying insurance to pay for small expenses. So, to me, a plan that doesn’t allow me to claim much, even if it’s cheap, is not worth considering. Remember, you are buying insurance to protect you from future big bills, not to break even.

At the end of the day, you will have to decide whether you need pet insurance in the first place, when is the best time to get the insurance, and what sort of coverage you need.

Know your budget

If money isn’t an issue, everyone will buy the best insurance plans. But money is an issue for most of us.

Don’t bite off more than you can chew when picking which insurance plan to purchase. If you don’t think you can afford a more expensive plan in the long-run, then maybe choosing an affordable plan is a better option. When you cancel an insurance plan, you lose any lock-in premium or co-insurance that you got when you first signed up.

Also, keep in mind that some pet insurance premiums increase as your pet ages, so it would only get more and more expensive.

An option you can consider is to buy a cheaper plan and upgrade it in the future. Buying insurance early usually comes with benefits, regardless of the plan you choose. For example, you may lock-in lower co-insurance with the insurance company when your dog is still young.  Young dogs may also be exempted from pre-insurance blood tests.

Thus, if you are planning to get pet insurance, get it early, even when you can only afford the cheapest plan.

Other factors to consider

Besides specific coverage and premiums, there are certain things you should consider before deciding on which insurance to go for.

1. Congenital and hereditary conditions cover

Some insurance plans cover congenital and hereditary conditions (that are not pre-existing) for younger pets. If your dog is not from a reputable breeder or is a breed that is notorious for certain health conditions, you may want to make sure that your pet insurance covers them.

2. Surgical vs. non-surgical cover

Some pet insurance cover eligible outpatient bills, which are great as illnesses don’t always require surgery to treat. However, take note of exclusions. In the same premium range, you may also sacrifice better in-patient treatment coverage. Best of both worlds come at a cost.

2. Lifetime coverage

Some insurance plans only cover your pet up to a certain age. That means that even if your pet was insured her whole life, she will cease to be covered when she reaches a certain age – the time of her life when she’s prone to age-related health problems.

It is therefore important to consider this when buying pet insurance.

3. Pre-insurance check-ups

Some insurance companies do not require any health check-up before enrollment while others may require you to send your pet for a physical check-up and even blood tests. As a client, you will obviously prefer as little checks as possible before enrollment to avoid the possibility of any coverage exclusions.

4. Choice of clinics

If you are particular about which vet your pet sees, you would want to make sure that your pet insurance covers medical care from any vet clinic and hospital. That also applies to the pre-insurance health check-up and blood tests. You may find it beneficial to go to a vet you prefer.

Some insurance companies also offer discounts that you may want to leverage on for pre-insurance checks at partner clinics.

ALSO READ: List of Recommended Vets in Singapore

5. Claim ease and speed

You may not think of it now, but the speed of which your insurance company processes your claim and reimburses you is probably going to make a big difference. You don’t want to be in a situation where your claims take ages to settle and you have to keep chasing for reimbursement.

Check with the insurance company on how to file claims and how long they would take to reimburse you.

6. Customer experience

From getting a quote, asking questions, to purchasing a plan, your experience with the insurance company and consultant should leave you feeling valued and comfortable. If the relationship isn’t good at the start, you can’t expect it to be good when you need them most.

Common insurance terms


Co-insurance is the percentage of the eligible bills you have to shoulder. So, if your co-insurance is 20% and your claimable bills come up to be $5,000, you have to pay $1,000.


The deductible is the fixed portion of the claim that you have to shoulder, after co-insurance, if any.

So if your insurance’s deductible is $200, you have to bear a total of $1,200. ($1,000 co-insurance + $200 deductible). Your insurance company will take up the rest of the claimable amount, which is $3,800, subject to your plan’s annual limit.

Waiting period

After enrollment, you have to wait for a certain period of time before you can start claiming insurance for your pet. That is what insurance companies call the “waiting period”. This is to prevent people from abusing the system by filing large claims right after purchase and cancelling afterward.

Pre-existing condition

A pre-existing condition is a health condition that your pet already has before the insurance starts or gets during the waiting period. Most insurance plans do not cover pre-existing conditions.

If you live in Singapore, we recommend you to read:

Happy Tails Pet Insurance vs. Liberty PetCare Comparison

AIA Paw Safe Pet Insurance

If you live in North America, Reviews.com has a pretty cool pet insurance comparison page. Check it out here.

Subscribe to join our pack and find us on Facebook and Instagram.

Sarah Chong on FacebookSarah Chong on GoogleSarah Chong on InstagramSarah Chong on PinterestSarah Chong on TwitterSarah Chong on Youtube
Sarah Chong
Founder at Vanillapup
Sarah is Latte's mama. She loves dogs, shopping, travelling, and reading novels. Using her background in social media and advertising, she started Vanillapup in 2013. Latte is her first and only dog, and she finds joy in sharing her learnings as a dog owner with everyone.
Click to comment

We love to hear from our readers. Please leave a comment below :)

To Top